The Lighthouse Writers Top-Secret Blog

All the latest news, ideas, and opinions from Denver's Independent Literary Center:

MFA vs NYC vs the Rest of Us

Chad Harbach’s essay “MFA vs. NYC” has received quite a bit of attention. If you’re interested in contemporary American literature, it’s well worth your time to read it. In essence, Harbach describes a growing bifurcation in American fiction:

…one condensed in New York, the other spread across the diffuse network of provincial college towns that spans from Irvine, Calif., to Austin, Texas, to Ann Arbor, Mich., to Tallahassee, Fla… The superficial differences between these two cultures can be summed up charticle-style: short stories vs. novels; Amy Hempel vs. Jonathan Franzen; library copies vs. galley copies; Poets & Writers vs. the New York ObserverWonder Boys vs. The Devil Wears Prada; the Association of Writers and Writing Programs conference vs. the Frankfurt Book Fair; departmental parties vs. publishing parties; literary readings vs. publishing parties; staying home vs. publishing parties. But the differences also run deep. Each culture has its own canonical works and heroic figures; each has its own logic of social and professional advancement.

…one could, for instance, live a long, full life in New York without ever hearing of Stuart Dybek, a canonical MFA-culture story writer who oversaw the Western Michigan program for decades before moving on to Northwestern. A new Gary Shteyngart novel, meanwhile, will be met with indifference at most MFA programs. Entire such NYC and MFA rosters could be named.

MFA vs NYC vs the Rest of Us -- but which one is Moe?

MFA vs NYC vs the Rest of Us — but which one is Moe?

Of course you could name a variety of objections to this kind of generalization (e.g., there are any number of writers outside of New York and the university programs who are doing just fine), but if you glance around at the overall shape of the current literary landscape, it’s hard to completely dismiss Harbach’s thesis.

But I found myself wondering, where does the Lighthouse fit into this? Although some of the classes that the Lighthouse offers are similar to what might be found in an MFA program, there are important differences. For one, because the Lighthouse is not tied to an academic calender of weekly meetings and a two year degree, it can encourage longer works, like novels. For another, the Lighthouse’s audience is broader than any single university campus, and so it has a vested interest in facilitating and encouraging a broader community of writers and readers.

It’s understandable that Harbach would ignore literary nonprofits like the Lighthouse (other examples include the Loft and Grub Street), since they are relatively new, and the role they will play in literature in the future is not yet clear. But they are growing, and I believe they will play a role.

Harbach’s vision of the future seems rather grim, with literary fiction dependent on academia for income and careers.

What will happen? Economically speaking, the MFA system has announced its outsize ambitions, making huge investments in infrastructure and personnel, and offering gaudy salaries and propitious working conditions to secure top talent. The NYC system, on the other hand, presents itself as cautious and embattled, devoted to hanging on. And a business model that relies on tuition and tax revenue (the top six MFA programs, according to Poets & Writers, are part of large public universities); the continued unemployability of twentysomethings; and the continued hunger of undergraduates for undemanding classes, does seem more forward-looking than one that relies on overflow income from superfluous books by celebrities, politicians, and their former lovers. It was announced recently that Zadie Smith—one of the few writers equipped by fame to do otherwise—has accepted a tenured position at NYU, presumably for the health insurance; perhaps this marks the beginning of the end, a sign that in the future there will be no NYC writers at all, just a handful of writers accomplished enough to teach in NYC. New York will have become—as it has long been becoming—a place where some writers go for a wanderjahr or two between the completion of their MFAs and the commencement of their teaching careers. No one with “literary” aspirations will expect to earn a living by publishing books; the glory days when publishers still waffled between patronage and commerce will be much lamented.

But his conclusion made me think of Lighthouse:

The writers, even more so than now, will write for other writers. And so their common ambition and mission and salvation, their profession—indeed their only hope—will be to make writers of us all.

Not everyone will publish of course, but I do believe, actually, that we all should be writers; that’s called literacy. And everyone should be welcomed into the community of writers and readers. And that is where the Lighthouse, and organizations like the Lighthouse, can play an outsized role.

About Nick Arvin

Author of The Reconstructionist + a couple other books.

6 comments on “MFA vs NYC vs the Rest of Us

  1. andreadupree
    February 28, 2011

    Love the idea that “we should all be writers.” It makes nothing but sense to me, and all of the rest of the in-fighting and generalizing, to me, is a symptom of scarce resources–the feeling some people have that if you get yours, I won’t get mine. Thousands of dedicated, talented folks are vying for a miniscule (and ever-shrinking) bit of validation and remuneration by way of publishing, and even the best of the best can fall into bitterness and despair. But we need each other and we shouldn’t forget it!

  2. Kathy Doherty
    February 28, 2011

    I think of Lighthouse as a true beacon – yes, even in Denver. It is not the writing alone that makes me proud to be associated with Lighthouse. The fact that Lighthouse spreads the story and programs of writing to young people and offers grants for those unable to pay the fees for classes should not be dismissed as a small thing. Lighthouse is working with and for the writers of the future. Lighthouse has NEVER made me feel ‘less than’ or ‘small’ because I have no novel. It is the love of writing and reading that comes from everyone there, students and instructors. I don’t believe that would be available in many other places.

    • andreadupree
      February 28, 2011

      Wow–thanks for the great note! Maybe we should start a LH support group for those of us “without novels.” We’re not so small, right? Especially if we measure ourselves as a collective. 🙂 And thanks, too, for your words about classes. We’re working right now to establish a fund for writers who’d like to take workshops but can’t afford them. More on that to come!

  3. mjhenry
    March 1, 2011

    In many ways, writing has become a basic way of communicating with one another (as opposed to, say, writing letters), as well as a powerful way to make sense of this often fractured world. And the simple mechanical process of publishing is so much simpler and accessible to all (as opposed to say, the Gutenberg Bible printed on the very first printing press).

    Why not? Why not all be writers? We are not all going to be famous writers, but we do each have our audience–our people (as in, like, Lighthouse, perhaps).

  4. Aray
    March 1, 2011

    Totally agree, Nick (and all). I’ve always been puzzled by those who bemoan the MFA machine. MFA students are buying books and reading them, and they’re likely to continue doing so for the rest of their lives. What’s wrong with that? We can’t complain that there aren’t enough readers and at the same time shake our fists at programs that allow writers to devote a year or more to the appreciation of literature. So hurray for writing centers like Lighthouse, MFA programs, and literary New Yorkers! The tent is big enough for all of us.

  5. Rebecca Snow
    March 1, 2011

    Nice point, Aray. Now I don’t feel like such a shmuck for getting my MFA. And I really appreciate those grants for kids, mentioned above. My son has gotten a lot out of those workshops! I can’t wait for a grant for poor adults like me 🙂 I hope to take a poetry class or two while finishing my novel draft. No more novel workshopping, I’ve decided, until I finish an entire first draft. Everyone’s process is different . . .

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s


This entry was posted on February 28, 2011 by in Uncategorized, Writing.

Enter your email address to subscribe to this blog and receive notifications of new posts by email.

Join 640 other followers

Follow us on Twitter!

%d bloggers like this: